top of page

Judge Rules Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron Must Answer DRAM Collusion Claims

2 hours ago
3 min read

A federal judge in San Jose has ruled that Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron must answer a proposed class-action lawsuit accusing them of conspiring to restrict the supply of DRAM memory chips. U.S. District Judge Noël Wise denied the companies' motion to dismiss in an order signed November 14, 2026.


The decision does not mean the companies did anything wrong. It means the plaintiffs have pleaded enough for the case to move forward into the next stage of litigation.


What the Lawsuit Alleges


The case, Garciaguirre v. Samsung Electronics, was brought by 17 consumers and small businesses from five states, according to the order. They allege that the three companies, which the court described as the industry's oligopolists, coordinated to cut and lock up supply of conventional DRAM.


The complaint points to several moves: production cuts after demand fell in late 2022, a shift toward high-bandwidth memory (HBM) used in AI systems, an exit from older DDR3 and DDR4 products, and a failure to expand capacity. Tom's Hardware reported the plaintiffs tie those moves to a shortage in which prices rose by as much as 500% in a year.


The Companies' Defense


The defendants argued that each company made "rational" choices consistent with its own independent self-interest, according to the order. They also argued the case was a rerun of an earlier DRAM lawsuit that the Ninth Circuit dismissed in 2022, which involved a 2016 to 2018 supply restriction.


At the hearing, the companies cited the late Judge Richard Posner's observation that competitors in concentrated markets "watch each other like hawks." In other words, similar behavior can come from watching rivals, not from an agreement.


That argument is a standard one in antitrust cases. Under U.S. law, parallel conduct by competitors is not illegal by itself; plaintiffs must show an actual agreement. At the pleading stage, courts look for so-called plus factors that make an agreement more plausible than independent action.


Why the Judge Let It Proceed


Judge Wise disagreed with that framing at this early stage. "Plaintiffs' allegations go beyond hawks watching each other; their contentions are more akin to hawks flying in formation – an activity that hawks ordinarily do not do," she wrote.


She noted that it is possible each decision was made independently. But under Ninth Circuit law, a plaintiff relying on circumstantial evidence only needs to plead facts that are "largely" inconsistent with independent conduct and largely consistent with coordinated action. "The Court finds Plaintiffs have done so here," she wrote.


TrendForce, citing Korean outlet KPI News, reported that the court found the shift to HBM alone was not enough to suggest collusion, given its higher profitability, but weighed it together with the other alleged conduct.


What It Means for Business


For companies, the ruling is a reminder of how antitrust risk works in concentrated markets. When a few large firms make similar decisions at similar times, those decisions can later be read as evidence, even if each one had a business rationale. Documentation of independent decision-making matters.


For buyers of memory, from PC makers to small repair shops, the case is worth watching. Two of the named plaintiffs are small computer businesses, which shows that supply shocks in a component market can reach far down the chain.


What Comes Next


The order requires the defendants to file their answers by December 7, 2026, and sets the initial case management conference for January 12, 2027. Discovery, class certification and any trial are still ahead, and the companies have not been found liable for anything. The complaint does not seek a specific damages figure, TrendForce reported.


Court Magazine will follow the case as it develops. For more plain-language coverage of the business rulings that shape markets, keep reading our Business section.

Comments


bottom of page